
+ Through the prayers of our holy mothers and fathers, Lord Jesus Christ our God, have mercy on us and save us. Amen.

"It is better for a truthful person to tell a lie, than for a liar
to tell the truth." Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Conspiracy and Imprisonment: 1940-1945, Vol. 16, Fortress Press.
Nearly every week, when I can, I devour every issue of The Christian Century. Whilst others await monthly issues of their favorite visual and literary aversion, The Christian Century comes to me like a delicious "liebfraumilch." The lastest issue marked August 12, 2008, rang my bell or rather evoked a chime in me long dead. I remember my days at Candler School of Theology sitting in on a class about the German theologian Dietrich Bonhoeffer who was tragically executed at the hands of Nazis. My professor who was German himself, Dr. Sigfried Hoffman, taught the class like a contemporary of Bonhoeffer's. For some reason I always identified strongly with brother Dietrich.
Andrew Root a professor at Luther Seminary in St. Paul, MN wrote a fantastic article about Fox TV's show "Moment of Truth". The show features contestants whose response to questions are measured by a polygraph, supposedly revealing who is truthful and who is not. Root thoughtfully says that a polygraph measures doubt, but it does not measure truth. Roots article goes on to expose that the TV show has no interest in the truth since it does not have any interest in the human relationships that the show seeks to betray. In other words truth is not something that is non-contexual, but rather is rooted in relationships. At times our humanity is very vulnerable, our relationships are a far greater truth to be protected. To tell the truth out of context expresses doubt rather than truth. I know this all sounds so convoluted, so let me put it in a parable:
I learned today that my favorite neighbor, Margaret was told that the authorities in another city had found her sister dead. The report said that Margaret's sister may have been dead for a week. Margaret is very upset as you can imagine. Margaret would often have conversations with me about her sister who had a very serious addiction to alcohol. The family had been so concerned that they all had once participated in an intervention which worked to no avail. In earlier years when Margaret was asked about her sister by others, if she was an alcoholic--a "lost cause" some would say, Margaret would always say that "my sister is OK." Margaret always told the truth in that her sister's relationship with her was OK. In no way could Margaret dismiss her sister due to the judgements or the non-contexual "concrete truth" that overode the "situational/principled truth". Margaret was faithful to her relationship with her sister.
Ok, some of you may be asking, what has gotten into Tim's crawl? Well here it goes, over the span of my vocational life I have been privy to, sat in upon, been subjected to "truth-digging do- gooders". In as much as these very righteous warriors of the church would implement their causes with "inquisitions" they would leave divisive and bitter pain in their wake. When I sat before a committee of investigation in the United Methodist Church nearly 20 years ago, I was asked if I were a "self-avowed, practicing homosexual". My response to the question had nothing to do with my integrity, it had to do with "information as power" which would indicate certain death in the UMC world. As latter days would have it, you see that I am no longer part of the "bretheren" in the UMC. I saw that it was a context unsafe for me and my family. I guarded my secrets and chose to let others who love me handle those secrets. As Bonhoeffer would say, "a boundary was being crossed and liars use truth to violate boundaries in order to humiliate," and control. In another instance I had to sit and listen to the scornful words of an accuser who said that a person in leadership in our community is unfit due to being an alcoholic, even though this person was in recovery for many years. In the confrontation that I mediated, the accusers were constantly saying they were "only telling the truth." Somewhere through the unfortunate meeting I realized that there was no concern for the person by the accusers. It was an act of deception in order to gain power and to pay back this person for standing up to them.
I am always amazed at what happens in the name of the "truth". When truth is used as a weapon or as a means to betray the greater concrete truth of our relationships we only become flapping trivialists who know facts. St. James termed it as a "flaming tongue which sets many a forest aflame." Telling the truth is not a pornographic display of our inner most feelings and thoughts, telling the truth means living up to and into the contextual reality of our lives--as we live them in relationship with one another. As we struggle with literalists who distort our humanity in the Church, those "truth keepers" who protect the status quo in compartmentalized structures of power we forget that truth is contextual most of the time and factual less of the time. I know, I know this shakes another foundation in the centers of bibliolatry. I suppose, once again, it is the essence, the spirit of truth that reigns supreme even while encased in the messiness of humanity. Dietrich Bonhoeffer staked his life on living into this truth. He was an activist, he did break the law, he was fully aware of the frailty of his humanity, he loved his neighbors and undermined the liars who tried to dehumanize with propoganda millions of Jewish, Gypsies, and gay/lesbian people.
Sadly, the liars and the inquisitors lie outside my contextual circle of truthfulness, so what am I to do? My good ol' Evangelical preaching uncle would say, "evangelize and convert!" Oh no, here we go again. I think I will accept the messy humanity part and try to tell the truth as best as I can.
Join me August 17 at God Talk, 9:30 AM, Sunday and we can talk more about this and I'll bring the Christian Century with me. -TMM